Selective Collective · YA

The Selective Collective: Wentworth Hall


The Selective Collective’s first January pick:


Wentworth Hall by Abby Grahame

In conjunction with the season premiere of Downton Abbey this past Sunday, or first January book is Wentworth Hall by Abby Grahame.

Eighteen-year-old Maggie Darlington has turned into an entirely different person. The once spirited teen is now passive and reserved. A change Lord and Lady Darlington can’t help but be grateful for.
     It’s 1912, and the Darlingtons of Wentworth Hall have more than just the extensive grounds to maintain. As one of Britain’s most elite families, they need to keep up appearances that things are as they have always been…even as their carefully constructed faÇade rapidly comes undone.
     Maggie has a secret. And she’s not the only one…the handsome groom Michael, the beautiful new French nanny Therese, the Darlingtons’ teenage houseguests Teddy and Jessica, and even Maggie’s younger sister Lila are all hiding something. Passion, betrayal, heartache, and whispered declarations of love take place under the Darlingtons’ massive roof. And one of these secrets has the power to ruin the Darlingtons forever.
     When scandalous satires start appearing in the newspaper with details that closely mirror the lives of the Darlingtons, everyone is looking over their shoulder, worrying their scandal will be next. Because at Wentworth Hall, nothing stays secret for long.


Maggie Darlington, eldest daughter of the Darlington clan, circa England in 1912, has just returned from a year abroad with her mother, new baby brother and the baby’s nanny, Therese.  She’s returned home a different woman.  She left a wild, spontaneous girl, but she’s more than matured since she’s been away.  She’s no longer the sweet, supportive sister to Lila or the friend she was to her maid Nora and their stable hand, Michael, with whom Maggie had been especially close.  And she’s clearly hiding something, but she’s not the only one.

Michael, the stable boy who grew up alongside the Darlington children, is confused as to why Maggie is not the same girl she was and why she hasn’t spoken to him in the two months since she returned.  He confides in his friend, Maggie’s maid, Nora, but Nora cannot account for Maggie’s sudden change, either.

Therese, the French nanny who arrived with Maggie and Lady Darlington after their year on the continent, seems to be hiding something, as well.  Not only that, but it seems she’s also figured out a few secrets.  What are her ulterior motives?  Is she trying to get close to Michael?


The Darlightons, a prominent old family in Sussex, England, has fallen into dire straights.  In an effort to resolve their cash flow problems, Lord Darlington has invited the orphaned seventeen year old twins of an old military cohort and friend to stay with them until they turn 18 and receive their inheritance.  He hopes they will repay his kindness with a little kindness of their own.  And what a nice surprise it would be if 18 year old Maggie would become engaged to young Teddy, the orphaned heir.  It would certainly solve a few problems.  Suddenly, the local paper is publishing a scathing satire that seems to slyly depict the Darlingtons and everyone is a suspect, from young Lila to the new houseguests and old servants.  Who is writing them?  Why is Maggie avoiding Michael?  What is Therese hiding?

Overall Thoughts:

I haven’t seen Downton Abbey, though it’s definitely on my list.  But I love a good historical romance, which is what I thought this would be.  It didn’t live up to those expectations because there are far too many characters for it to be classified as a Romance, not that there wasn’t love affairs aplenty throughout the book.  I’ve read a lot of Regency-era fiction, so I understand the background and the family’s adherence to the social structure and their need to avoid scandal of any sort.  I also understand the money issues and why Lord Darlington would try to marry off his daughter to the highest bidder.  I am not sure the audience that this book is aiming for would appreciate the importance that is placed on money and status and remaining in the good graces of society.

It’s hard to write a review without giving too much away, though the questions are answered far sooner than I expected them to be.  Initially I liked Maggie, who seemed to be the main character (she was the first person introduced to us, so I guess I gravitated to her), but as the story went on and we saw her through the other characters eyes, she seemed cold.  It wasn’t until I found out her secret that I began to warm to her again, which I guess was the point?  Also, I liked the other characters (especially Lila) and I felt more of a connection with them.  I wish there were more character development because without it, I wasn’t invested enough to really care what happened to Maggie and there was just too much going on that was resolved too quickly.  I am not sure if this is the beginning of a series, and if that is the case, it would be a great opportunity to learn more about these people and become more attached to them.

Liked our review?  Check out all the other great SC posts about this book!

Casting Call:  Who would you cast in Wentworth Hall? – Brittany @ The Book Addict’s Guide

Author Q & A + Giveaway: Abby Grahame -Tee @ YA Crush

Roudtable Discussion: Wentworth Hall – Sandie & Diana @ Teen Lit Rocks

Freebie Post:   Wentworth Hall Style – Candice @ The Grown-Up YA

Thanks to Simon & Schuster for sending us copies for review.

6 thoughts on “The Selective Collective: Wentworth Hall

  1. I agree, I just wanted to get to know each character juuuust a bit more – Then I think we could have really locked in the story.
    Great review! 🙂 As always.

  2. Definitely didn’t like how everything was resolved super quickly towards the end. It made the book kind of… I don’t know. I think I liked it enough to say I liked it, but overall it wasn’t a favorite. There were just too many opportunities to develop and things just weren’t.

    1. I think there were too many cooks in the kitchen. if it had revolved around one or two characters, it would have been much more effective, narratively speaking

  3. I love the layout of this review! This was a tough book. There was, I think, potential for it to be fun, or to be romantic, but it just fell short. You’re right when you say there were too many cooks in the kitchen. The story with the twins coming into the household could have been so much more interesting and dramatic, but nothing really went anywhere there. It was like there were too many balls in the air. And I would have loved to know more about Michael, but that part of the story wasn’t really fully developed. We just hear bits and pieces after the fact. There were portions I enjoyed, but it didn’t quite hit the mark for me.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s